top of page
Search

Pole Barn vs. Post-Frame Building: Is There Actually a Difference?

midplainsbuildings
Oct 2
4 min read
Custom post-frame shop building in Eastern Nebraska by Mid-Plains Building Solutions
Custom post-frame shop building in Eastern Nebraska by Mid-Plains Building Solutions

If you’re planning a shop, barn, garage, equipment building, or other rural structure in Nebraska, you’ve probably heard both “pole barn” and “post-frame building.”

A lot of people use the terms interchangeably.

They’re related, but they are not quite the same thing.

The simplest way to think about it is this:

A pole barn is a traditional type of building that uses poles or posts as the primary vertical supports.

A post-frame building is the broader, more modern structural system that uses widely spaced structural posts or columns with roof framing, girts, and purlins to create the building shell.

The National Frame Building Association defines a post-frame building system as one using wood posts as columns with trusses or rafters as roof framing, along with secondary framing members such as girts and purlins. NFBA

The American Wood Council also notes that post-frame structures are sometimes referred to as pole buildings or pole barns, which is one reason the terminology gets confusing. American Wood Council


Why people still call them pole barns

The phrase pole barn has been around for a long time, especially in agricultural areas.

Traditionally, a pole barn was exactly what the name suggests: a straightforward farm building built with vertical poles placed into the ground and a relatively simple roof and wall system.

They were often used for:

  • hay storage

  • livestock

  • farm equipment

  • machinery

  • general agricultural storage

Today, homeowners and property owners still use “pole barn” as a catch-all phrase for almost any large wood-post building.

That does not necessarily mean the structure is being built the same way an older farm pole barn would have been.


What makes modern post-frame construction different?

Modern post-frame construction can be much more engineered and versatile than the old image many people have of a basic pole barn.

Instead of conventional wall studs placed closely together, the building uses larger structural posts or laminated columns spaced farther apart.

Those primary posts support the roof system, while girts and purlins form the secondary framing.

That system can be engineered for a wide range of uses and loads. NFBA describes post-frame as an engineered wood-frame system that can be used for agricultural, residential, commercial, industrial, and municipal applications. NFBA

That is why modern post-frame buildings can be used for much more than barns.

We commonly see them considered for:

  • custom shops

  • detached garages

  • RV and boat storage

  • equipment buildings

  • agricultural buildings

  • hobby shops

  • workshops

  • commercial buildings

  • combination shop and office space

  • residential-style buildings


Does a post-frame building have to have posts buried in the ground?

No.

This is another common misconception.

Modern post-frame buildings can use several foundation approaches. Posts may be embedded and supported on isolated footings, or they may be attached to piers, concrete walls, masonry foundations, or slabs depending on the design. NFBA

That means “post-frame” does not automatically mean untreated wood buried directly into dirt.

The correct foundation system depends on the building, soil conditions, intended use, engineering, local requirements, and the owner’s long-term goals.


Is post-frame cheaper than traditional construction?

It can be.

One of the main advantages of post-frame construction is structural efficiency.

Because the system uses larger structural members spaced farther apart, it can reduce the amount of framing required compared with some conventional systems.

NFBA specifically identifies construction efficiency, cost efficiency, and design flexibility among the benefits of modern post-frame construction. NFBA

But there is an important distinction:

A basic agricultural storage building and a fully insulated custom shop are not the same project.

The final cost depends heavily on things like:

  • building dimensions

  • wall height

  • roof pitch

  • truss design

  • concrete

  • insulation

  • interior liner or drywall

  • electrical

  • plumbing

  • HVAC

  • overhead doors

  • windows

  • site preparation

  • grading

  • driveway access

  • utilities

  • engineering

  • finish level

That is why comparing buildings only by square-foot price can be misleading.


Is post-frame construction only for rural properties?

Not at all.

Post-frame construction is especially common on rural acreage because it works very well for large clear-span buildings, shops, barns, and equipment storage.

But the structural system itself is not limited to agriculture.

Post-frame buildings can be designed with residential-looking exteriors, porches, stone accents, conventional siding, metal siding, multiple rooflines, large windows, and finished interiors.

The framing method does not dictate what the finished building has to look like.


Custom post-frame shop building in Eastern Nebraska by Mid-Plains Building Solutions
Custom post-frame shop building in Eastern Nebraska by Mid-Plains Building Solutions

Pole barn vs. post-frame: which term should you use?

For a homeowner or property owner, either term will usually communicate the basic idea.

But when you start talking about engineering, permitting, specifications, and pricing, post-frame building is the more accurate term for most modern projects.

That distinction matters because a properly designed post-frame structure is a complete building system, not simply a few poles with metal attached to them.


What should you focus on instead of the name?

The better questions are:

How will the building be used?

Will it be cold storage, a heated shop, equipment storage, RV storage, a hobby space, or something closer to finished residential space?

What clear height do you need?

Large equipment, lifts, RVs, boats, and future lofts can all affect building height.

How large should the doors be?

Door size can dramatically affect the front wall framing and structural design.

Will the building be insulated now or later?

Planning for insulation during initial design is usually easier than trying to retrofit it later.

What site work is required?

Raw acreage may need grading, a building pad, drainage work, driveway construction, utility extensions, excavation, and concrete before the building itself can begin.

Those decisions usually matter far more than whether someone calls the finished structure a pole barn or a post-frame building.


Building a post-frame shop in Eastern Nebraska and Omaha Metro Area

At Mid-Plains Building Solutions, we help property owners plan projects from the ground up.

That can include:

The goal is not simply to put up a shell.

It is to make sure the building size, site, access, concrete, utilities, and intended use all make sense together before construction begins.

If you are considering a custom shop, garage, agricultural building, or post-frame structure in Eastern Nebraska, we can help you work through the project before you commit to a design that may not fit your property or budget.


Mid-Plains Building Solutions

Eastern Nebraska

402-512-3818



 
 
 

Comments


© 2021 by Mid-Plains Building Solutions. All rights reserved.

  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
bottom of page